Tracking Trout

Mike Trout vs.Willie Mays/Mickey Mantle/Miguel Cabrera

The 2014 season is the start of a new era in baseball history, as in the past, an all-time great hitter has always led the way of each new era. At baseballgreatesthitters.com we feel Mike Trout will be the all-time great to lead the way as the top hitter in this new era in baseball. In the first three years of his baseball career, the numbers put up by Mike Trout compare very favorably to the numbers of Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays and Miguel Cabrera.

.

TABLE 1

Player Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points Edge
Mantle 1952 20 94 23 87 311 394 530 4.291 3
Mays 1954 23 119 41 110 345 411 667 4.572 1
Cabrera 2004 21 101 33 112 294 366 512 4.242 4
Trout 2012 20 129 30 102 326 399 564 4.380 2
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points Edge
Mantle 1953 21 105 21 92 295 398 497 4.258 4
Mays 1955 24 123 51 127 319 400 657 4.559 1
Cabrera 2005 22 106 33 116 323 385 561 4.348 3
Trout 2013 21 109 27 97 323 432 557 4.372 2
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points Edge
Mantle 1954 22 129 27 102 300 408 525 4.347 2
Mays 1956 25 101 36 84 296 369 557 4.308 4
Cabrera 2006 23 112 26 114 339 430 568 4.406 1
Trout 2014 22 115 36 111 287 377 561 4.323 3
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points Edge
Mantle 1955 23 121 37 99 306 431 611 4.471 2
Mays 1957 26 112 35 97 333 407 626 4.474 1
Cabrera 2007 24 91 34 119 320 401 565 4.355 4
Trout 2015 23 104 41 90 299 402 590 4.361 3
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points Edge
Mantle 1956 24 132 52 130 353 464 705 4.717 1
Mays 1958 27 121 29 96 347 419 583 4.453 2
Cabrera 2008 25 85 37 127 292 349 537 4.255 4
Trout 2016 24 123 29 100 315 441 550 4.387 3
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points Edge
Mantle 1957 25 121 34 94 365 512 665 4.654 1
Mays 1959 28 125 34 104 313 381 583 4.403 2
Cabrera 2009 26 96 34 103 324 396 547 4.328 4
Trout 2017 25 92 33 72 306 442 629 4.401 3
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points Edge
Mantle 1958 26 127 42 97 304 443 592 4.476 2
Mays 1960 29 107 29 103 319 381 555 4.352 4
Cabrera 2010 27 111 38 126 328 420 622 4.477 1
Trout 2018 26 101 39 79 312 460 628 4.452 3
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points Edge
Mantle 1959 27 104 31 75 285 390 514 4.259 3.
Mays 1961 30 129 40 123 308 393 584 4.446 1,
Cabrera 2011 28 111 30 105 344 448 586 4,444 2.
Trout 2019 27
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points Edge
Mantle 1960 28 119 40 94 275 399 558 4.354 3.
Mays 1962 31 130 49 141 304 384 615 4.501 1.
Cabrera 2012 29 109 44 139 330 393 606 4.455 2.
Trout 2020 28
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points
Mantle 1961 29 131 54 128 317 447 687 4.645 1.
Mays 1963 32 115 38 103 314 380 582 4.399 3.
Cabrera 2013 30 103 44 137 348 442 636 4.544 2.
Trout 2021 29
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points
Mantle 1962 30 96 30 89 321 486 605 4.486 1.
Mays 1964 33 121 47 111 296 383 607 4.441 2.
Cabrera 2014 31 101 25 109 313 371 524 4.258 3.
Trout 2022 30
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points
Mantle 1964 32 92 35 111 303 423 591 4.419 2.
Mays 1965 34 118 52 112 317 398 645 4.523 1.
Cabrera 2015 32 64 18 76 338 440 534 4.278 3.
Trout 2023 31
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points
Mantle 1965 33 44 19 46 255 379 452 4.043 3.
Mays 1966 35 99 37 103 288 368 556 4.317 2.
Cabrera 2016 33 92 38 108 316 393 563 4.338 1.
Trout 2024 32
Year Age Runs H.R. RBI’s Avg. OB% Slg% Points
Mantle 1966 34 40 23 56 288 389 538 4.186 1.
Mays 1967 36 83 22 70 263 334 453 4.076 2.
Cabrera 2017 34 50 16 60 249 329 399 3.909 3.
Trout 2025 33
Mantle 1967 35 63 22 55 245 391 434 4.061 2.
Mays 1968 37 84 23 79 289 372 488 4.187 1.
Cabrera 2019 36
Trout 2026 34
Mantle 1968 36 57 18 54 237 385 398 3.996 2.
Mays 1969 38 64 13 58 283 362 437 4.059 1.
Cabrera 2019 37
Trout 2027
.

TABLE 2

YEAR 1 Rank 3-Year Recap
Mays 4.572 1. Mays 13,439
Trout 4.380 2. Trout 13,075
Mantle 4.291 3. Cabrera 12,996
Cabrera 4.242 4. Mantle 12,896
YEAR 2 Rank 4-Year Recap
Mays 4.559 1. Mays 17,913
Trout 4.372 2. Trout 17,436
Cabrera 4.348 3. Mantle 17,367
Mantle 4.258 4. Cabrera 17,351
YEAR 3 Rank 5-Year Recap
Cabrera 4.406 1. Mays 22,366
Mantle 4.347 2. Mantle 22,084
Trout 4.323 3. Trout 21,823
Mays 4.308 4. Cabrera 21,606
YEAR 4 Rank 6-Year Recap
Mays 4.474 1. Mays 26,769
Mantle 4.471 2. Mantle 26,738
Cabrera 4.355 3. Trout 26,224
Trout 4.361 4. Cabrera 25,934
YEAR 5 Rank 7-Year Recap
Mantle 4.717 1. Mantle 31,214
Mays 4.453 2. Mays 31,121
Trout 4.387 3. Trout 30,676
Cabrera 4.255 4. Cabrera 30,411
YEAR 6 Rank 8-Year Recap
Mantle 4.654 1. Mays 35,567
Mays 4.403 2. Mantle 35,473
Trout 4.401 3. Cabrera 34,855
Cabrera 4.328 4.
YEAR 7 Rank 9-Year Recap
Cabrera 4.477 1. Mays 40,068
Mantle 4.476 2. Mantle 39,827
Trout 4.452 3. Cabrera 39,310
Mays 4.352 4.
YEAR 8 Rank 10 Year Recap
Mays 4.446 1. Mantle 44,472
Cabrera 4.444 2. Mays 44,467
Mantle 4,259 3. Cabrera 43,854
Cabrera 4,444 4
Trout
YEAR 9 Rank 11 Year Recap
Mays 4,501 1. Mantle 48,958
Cabrera 4.455 2. Mays 48,908
Mantle 4,354 3. Cabrera 48,112
Trout 4
YEAR 10 Rank 12 Year Recap
Mantle 4,645 1. Mays 53,431
Cabrera 4,544 2. Mantle 53,377
Mays 4,399 3. Cabrera 52,390
Trout 4.
YEAR 11 Rank 13 Year Recap
Mantle 4.486 1 Mays 57,748
Mays 4.441 2 Mantle 57,420
Cabrera 4,258 3. Cabrera 56,728
Trout 4,

Back to Player Comparisons

.

Content copyright 2017. Joe Angelini. All rights reserved.