Manny Ramirez vs. Alex Rodriguez |

Alex Rodriguez vs. Manny Ramirez

The past 20 years has seen baseball produce two of the greatest right-handed hitters in the history of the game. Alex Rodriguez vs. Manny Ramirez is a very interesting comparison , both were top hitters of the steroid era and both players were found guilty of PED use, which puts the comparison on a level playing field.

Manny Ramirez (1993-2011) 14 full seasons, (seasons omitted 1993, 1994, 2009, 2010, 2011)
Alex Rodriguez (1994- 2016) 16 full seasons (seasons omitted1994, 1995, 2011, 2013)

Our Rank on our greatest hitter list Manny Ramirez # 16 Alex Rodriguez # 15
Comparing 14 Head to Head Seasons Manny Ramirez- 8, Alex Rodriguez – 6
The edge goes to Manny Ramirez

Player	Year	Age	Runs	H.R.	RBI’s	Avg.	OB%	Slg%	Points	Edge
Rodriguez	1996	20	141	36	123	358	414	631	4.530	Rodriguez
Ramirez	1995	23	85	31	107	308	402	558	4.313

Rodriguez	1997	21	100	23	84	300	350	496	4.167
Ramiriz	1996	24	94	33	112	309	399	582	4.353	Ramirez

Rodriguez	1998	22	123	42	124	310	360	560	4.352	Rodriguez
Ramirez	1997	25	99	26	88	328	415	538	4.311

Rodriguez	1999	23	110	42	111	285	357	586	4.324
Ramirez	1998	26	108	45	145	294	377	599	4.404	Ramirez

Rodriguez	2000	24	134	41	132	316	420	606	4.481
Ramirez	1999	27	131	44	165	333	442	663	4.613	Ramirez

Rodriguez	2001	25	133	52	135	318	399	622	4.502
Ramirez	2000	28	92	38	122	351	457	697	4.586	Ramirez

Rodriguez	2002	26	125	57	142	300	392	623	4.487	Rodriguez
Ramirez	2001	29	93	41	125	306	405	609	4.411

Rodriguez	2003	27	124	47	118	298	396	600	4.421
Ramirez	2002	30	84	33	107	349	450	647	4.494	Ramirez

Rodriguez	2004	28	112	36	106	286	375	512	4.254
Ramirez	2003	31	117	37	104	325	427	587	4.425	Ramirez

Rodriguez	2005	29	124	48	130	321	421	610	4.493	Rodriguez
Ramirez	2004	32	108	43	130	308	397	613	4.433

Rodriguez	2006	30	113	35	121	290	392	523	4.300
Ramirez	2005	33	112	45	144	292	388	594	4.411	Ramirez

Rodriguez	2007	31	143	54	156	314	422	645	4.579	Rodriguez
Ramirez	2006	34	79	35	102	321	439	619	4.421

Rodriguez	2008	32	104	35	103	302	392	573	4.335	Rodriguez
Ramirez	2007	35	84	20	88	296	388	493	4.180

Rodriguez	2009	33	78	30	100	286	402	532	4.249
Ramirez	2008	36	102	37	121	332	430	601	4.451	Ramirez

Rodriguez	2010	34	74	30	125	270	341	506	4.167
Ramirez

Rodriguez	2012	36	74	18	57	272	353	430	4.013
Ramirez

Rodriguez	2015	39	83	33	86	250	356	486	4.121
Ramirez

Back to Player Comparisons